Author: Alexander Beck, MPhil Candidate, Oxford University
Editor: Farrell Gregory, BA, Mansfield College
On May 12th, 2025, the Emerging Threats Group had the pleasure of hosting Mr. Andrew Badger — a seasoned corporate adviser and former U.S. intelligence officer. Drawing on his extensive experience in both government and the private sector, Mr. Badger delivered a compelling presentation on the complex and evolving threats to cultural heritage items and sites worldwide, and how emerging technologies can play a pivotal role in their protection.
The Nature of Cultural Heritage Destruction
The presentation began with an overview of the reasoning and processes surrounding the destruction and theft of antiquities. While antiquities are sometimes simply caught in the crossfire of conflicts, some actors may destroy cultural heritage items and sites on the basis of ideological motivation. Perhaps most notoriously, ISIS/ISIL has engaged in the destruction of such cultural heritage sites as Palmyra, as they represent a polytheistic and pre-Islamic tradition contrary to the Wahhabist beliefs this group espouses. As a symbolically poignant spectacle, this act of destruction possesses significant propaganda value.
Cultural heritage is also endangered for the sake of profit, as artifacts are stolen and sold. ISIS/ISIL also engaged in the sale of antiquities, demonstrating a financial motivation which also characterises the black market exchange of cultural artifacts by Italian mafias.
The Use of Intelligence Gathering to Protect Cultural Heritage
Next, the presentation described the various forms of intelligence gathering which can contribute to the protection of antiquities, how these forms of intelligence gathering are mutually reinforcing, and how HUMINT remains particularly relevant even in a digitised INT landscape. For example, monitoring illicit communications can provide insights while human assets can close any remaining information gaps and produce an overall clearer INT picture.
The use of INT to protect and recover antiquities was exemplified by the case of OPERATION DEMETRA, a multinational effort that saw a successful intervention in the black market exchange of Sicilian antiquities in the late 2010s. In this case, illicit networks were infiltrated, prosecutable evidence gained, and informants recruited. It was also noted that there are significant challenges regarding the protection of antiquities, as prosecuting criminals requires multinational cooperation, a corresponding legal framework, and a prosecutable threshold of evidence, which might not be easily met.
The Use of Emerging Tech to Protect Cultural Heritage
The presentation next moved to the role of AI in informing efforts to protect antiquities. AI is already employed in this capacity – Drones outfitted with AI technology have served to monitor heritage sites from a bird’s-eye view in Peru, tracking the illegal excavation of historic sites. AI can also be used in a predictive fashion by identifying trends in communication networks, which might signify the illegal exchange of antiquities, or by predicting the emergence of threats to heritage sites. As a monitoring and predictive tool, AI allows officials to allocate their resources more efficiently, gather prosecutable evidence, and trace the exchange networks that threaten antiquities.
However, it was also noted that there are challenges associated with digitised INT methodologies, such as biased datasets, poor access to encrypted and dark web sites, and ethical concerns regarding privacy. While recognising these hurdles, it was asserted that AI is a necessary law-enforcement tool in an increasingly digital landscape. Lastly, the presentation concluded with a discussion of Interpol-led OPERATION ATHENA and the EU-led SIGNIFICANCE project, both being AI-centred initiatives to assist legal authorities in the protection of antiquities, which exemplify the present and future potential of these technologies.