Skip to content Skip to footer

Review: Globally Critical Infrastructure: Sovereignty, Security, Fault Lines (17/11/25)

Author: Liberty Branston, BA, Hertford College
Editor:  Alexander Beck, MPhil Candidate, Oxford University

On Monday 17 November, the Emerging Threats Group welcomed Zachary Kallenborn for a deep-dive into the strategic implications of globally critical infrastructure (GCI)—the increasingly dense network of assets, supply chains, and systems whose disruption can reverberate across regions and reshape the balance of global security. Drawing on his recent article in Risk Analysis, Kallenborn outlined why infrastructure that lies outside any single state’s control has become central to geopolitical leverage, deterrence, and multi-domain competition.

Anchored in real-world chokepoints—from semiconductor foundries and rare-earth processing hubs to subsea cables and cross-border energy transit—his talk traced how these highly interconnected systems are eroding traditional assumptions about sovereignty and national resilience. The session urged ETG participants to adopt a broader systems-level perspective: one where vulnerability, governance, and opportunity are distributed across states, corporations, and entire industrial ecosystems.


I. Sovereignty and the Limits of National Control

Kallenborn began by reframing a core tension: national critical infrastructure policy is built on the premise that states can regulate, defend, and impose resilience standards on the assets they depend on. Yet the infrastructures most essential for global stability increasingly lie outside national jurisdiction—owned by multinational companies, embedded in foreign territory, or distributed across borders. This mismatch between political authority and operational reality is now a defining stress point of modern sovereignty.

As states rely on supply chains and systems they do not fully control, they face structural vulnerabilities that cannot be mitigated through domestic policy alone. Undersea cables—privately operated, geographically dispersed, and responsible for over 95% of global data transmission—exemplify the challenge. A single disruption, intentional or accidental, can simultaneously affect governments, markets, militaries, and civilian services across multiple continents. Sovereignty, in this context, becomes less about territorial dominion and more about navigating layered dependencies running through foreign jurisdictions and private networks.


II. Security, Strategic Leverage, and Systemic Vulnerability

The session’s second theme explored how GCI reshapes the security environment by creating new vectors for coercion, competition, and systemic risk. Concentrated nodes such as semiconductor foundries, rare-earth processing hubs, and energy transit corridors have become strategic leverage points. Their disruption can produce cascading effects: a failure in one region can degrade military readiness, stall critical manufacturing, and undermine digital and intelligence architectures far beyond the source of disruption.

Kallenborn stressed that traditional homeland-security frameworks—designed for national assets and territorial defence—are ill-suited for this landscape. In a world defined by GCI, defence extends into supply-chain strategy, foreign policy, cross-border investment controls, and international regulatory cooperation. Adversaries can exploit vulnerabilities in global networks without ever striking a state’s physical territory. The shift from localised attacks to systemic leverage requires a reimagining of how states conceptualise, prioritise, and resource security.


III. Emerging Fault Lines and Cascading Global Risk

Kallenborn then turned to the emerging fault lines shaping global infrastructure risk. These include governance gaps between national regulatory systems, opaque ownership structures within the private sector, and deep interdependencies between sectors that were never designed with global resilience in mind. When a facility or node underperforms or fails, the consequences can propagate through supply chains, industries, and national economies with unexpected speed and magnitude.

Semiconductor manufacturing offers a vivid illustration: disruptions at a single fabrication plant can trigger global shortages affecting defence platforms, industrial production, telecommunications, and essential digital services. Efficiency has driven global integration; fragility is its by-product. Understanding and mitigating these cascading risks requires tools that transcend national boundaries—from multilateral risk governance frameworks to collaborative scenario testing and shared resilience standards.


Kallenborn’s intervention underscored a strategic truth that sits at the heart of the ETG’s mission: the critical infrastructures underpinning modern society are no longer national systems—they are global architectures whose vulnerabilities and opportunities ripple across borders. As geopolitical competition intensifies and technological interdependence deepens, the ability to understand, govern, and safeguard these globally critical assets will define not just national resilience, but the stability of the international system itself. The Week 6 session made clear that the future of security lies not in defending isolated assets, but in managing the complex, interconnected ecosystem that sustains contemporary power.nt. If you would like to contribute send your draft or pitch to journal@emergingthreats.co.uk by 21st November.

Emerging Threats Working Group

Newsletter Signup

Socials
Menu
Contact Us

Oxford, United Kingdom

Email Us Here

Emerging Threats Working Group © 2026. All Rights Reserved.