Author: Alexander Beck, MPhil Candidate, Oxford University
Editor: Farrell Gregory, BA, Mansfield College
The Emerging Threats Group convened its fourth-week seminar, Hidden Frontiers: Emerging Threats, Black Swans, and Geopolitics in Defence and Security, moderated by Dr. Matthew Finch (Oxford Said Business School). The discussion brought together a diverse panel of experts — Latika Bourke (Australian National University), Dr. Sebastian Seidel (BWConsulting), Jutta Doberstein (author and filmmaker, New York Times), and Taylor El Hage (International SOS) — each offering insights from journalism, policy, foresight, and field experience.
The seminar sought to explore the unseen and under-discussed dimensions of global security — the “black swans” and emerging dynamics that could reshape the geopolitical landscape. Participants were invited to think beyond today’s headlines and identify what future generations may look back upon as the defining blind spots of our era. Over ninety minutes, the panel traversed issues of military readiness, societal resilience, the diffusion of technology, and the erosion of shared reality in an age of contestation and complexity.
I. Fragile Readiness: Health, Standardization, and Human Factors
The discussion opened with a reflection on the fragility of Western defence readiness. From a European perspective, it was noted that NATO’s manpower shortfalls, combined with the slow pace of recruitment and training, have made the “human factor” more vital than ever. Ensuring force health, maintaining medical supplies, and protecting personnel from emerging biological and chemical threats were described as being as critical as procurement or deterrence. These vulnerabilities underscored how logistical resilience remains the true backbone of military power.
It was further discussed that the global contest over standardization — the quiet but decisive process through which major states influence production norms, technological standards, and procurement frameworks — is often overlooked. By setting international standards, competitors can shape future defence supply chains, creating dependencies that may outlast diplomatic alignments. These “invisible levers” of influence will determine not only what equipment allied militaries buy, but also how interoperable they remain.
Expanding the frame to Africa’s Sahel region, the discussion described a “cradle of instability” that remains dangerously underappreciated in Western policy circles. Desertification, resource conflict, and the weaponization of information are converging to drive migration and state collapse. Non-state actors are adopting emerging technologies — including offline AI systems — to enhance propaganda, recruitment, and tactical coordination. Such developments signal the rise of a new era of asymmetric threats in which insurgent groups may wield tools once exclusive to states.
II. Preparedness, Community Resilience, and the Contestation of Reality
From the Sahel to Europe’s heartland, the conversation turned to societal preparedness and psychological resilience. Drawing on crisis-response research, it was observed that ordinary citizens are often catastrophically unprepared for disruption. A comparison to a volunteer fire brigade fumbling basic communications illustrated the broader point that populations have lost the muscle memory of hardship. The need for renewed civic education in resilience and mutual care was emphasized.
Building on this, participants discussed how governments have failed to articulate the reality that the world is neither at war nor at peace, but in a state of permanent contestation. This conceptual blindness inhibits societies from mobilizing against diffuse, non-kinetic threats such as cyberattacks, disinformation, and economic coercion. Traditional binary frameworks — peace versus war, Europe versus Indo-Pacific — are increasingly outdated. Instead, democratic societies must develop a shared threat map that connects vulnerabilities across regions, from undersea cable sabotage in the Baltics to drone incursions in the Indo-Pacific.
The discussion also explored how resilience must be cultivated not only through defence spending but through community engagement and practical education. Teaching digital literacy, supply resilience, and even forms of creative civic expression could help rebuild empathy and cohesion in societies accustomed to abundance. It was cautioned, however, that such renewal will require confronting entitlement, consumerism, and generational detachment from scarcity. The broader challenge, as one contributor noted, is to learn to see change not as loss but as adaptation.
III. Technology, Truth, and the New Battlespace
Attention then turned to how technology and information disorder are redefining geopolitics. It was argued that societies are reaching an “acceleration or bust” point with the internet and generative AI, where truth itself is becoming unstable. Misinformation, algorithmic bias, and the sheer overload of digital content are eroding citizens’ ability to discern reality. This has already disrupted democratic processes, as illustrated by examples of both successful and failed counter-disinformation efforts across Europe.
The conversation examined the weaponization of drone imagery and online propaganda, noting how extremist groups now use first-person footage of drone attacks for recruitment. Such gamification of conflict has blurred the lines between entertainment and warfare, producing powerful psychological and social effects. Related observations included the rise of community-based “drone sports” programs — competitions training teenagers in piloting drones — which, while intended as preparation, also reveal how technological militarization can be normalized through recreation.
When the discussion turned to AI and reality construction, several participants reflected on the challenges of confronting its implications. AI is already reshaping how societies perceive truth — not merely automating content, but filtering what people recognize as real. Yet amid this “boiling frog” dynamic, it was agreed that denial is no longer sustainable. As one observer reminded the group, invoking the lesson of the Black Swan metaphor: unseen realities are often hiding in plain sight.
The seminar concluded with a shared sense of urgency and paradox. While emerging technologies, climate crises, and shifting alliances present novel dangers, the most profound threat may be psychological — the widespread refusal to confront uncomfortable realities. Whether examining standardization, societal fragility, or AI’s distortion of truth, the discussion suggested that complacency and nostalgia may be the true black swans of our age.
Yet the session also highlighted paths forward: building cross-regional resilience, rethinking preparedness as a social project, and embracing adaptive governance capable of managing “safety at speed.” The Hidden Frontiers seminar underscored that anticipating the future of security requires not just better foresight tools, but deeper cultural and moral renewal — grounded in realism, empathy, and collective responsibility.